Making the decision to have a child - it's momentous. It is to decide forever to have your heart go walking around outside your body.-Elizabeth Stone
She had entered a puritanical decade, a demographic moment - whatever it was - when the best compliment you could get was, "You would make a terrific mother." The wolf whistle of the nineties.-Lorrie Moore, "Terrific Mother"
Birds of AmericaAlmost all of the women at the place I used to work have children. They spent the bulk of workplace "chit-chat" time talking about their kids because that is, to a great extent, what they are interested in. But I am not a mother and this sometimes made it hard to relate to them. Conversations started by the easy, innocent question "How was your weekend?" quickly turned from discussion on books read or movies watched into animated talk of the Johnny Jump-Up one mother got for cheap at a rummage sale and which diaper service is best.
When this happened I couldn't help feeling like an outsider at the white-columned Midwestern life insurance company where I used to make my living, where "family life" is so predominant it's taken for granted. There, I was that most unnatural of all species: a married woman without kids.
With every year the evidence mounted that I was an anomaly: like the women at work, many people I knew from high school and college were having children. The pressure I felt from this at one time was enormous, and it didn't help that some people, asking me when I was going to have kids, would treat my decision with disbelief. What could I
mean that I didn't want to reproduce like them? I even had a friend tell me that he thought it was good people like me who SHOULD have children, implying that I was somehow doing the world a dis-service if I didn't...
On a trip back to Seattle I went to the beach where I spent much of my childhood summers, this place I passed countless hours swimming, building intricate sand castles and moats, learning to turn somersaults and stand on my hands in the gentle lake water. While I was there, I noticed a familiar looking woman - a tough street chick I barely knew in high school, tattoos covered her body, she was wearing hoop earrings and her brassy blonde hair tucked up under a green John Deere hat. I hid behind my book, observing her, but not wanting to be recognized. I watched her go into the water with her son beside her and felt livid - what the hell, even she has a kid!?
It was a feeling of being left further and further behind by my entire generation. It was the fear of not being "normal," of being so in the minority that soon I would no longer be able to speak the local language.
**********************************************************************
Even with this cultural insistence that I have children, and the fears about being so different, I am still certain that I don't want kids. Despite what some might think, it has not been an easy choice.
My older brother emailed me: "I think you don't want to have kids because 'everyone does it' and you've always thought you were different, and that is the worst reason to not have kids."
I responded: "That's not it - it's because there are other things I want to do with my life, because I don't think I'm emotionally up to it, I don't think I can give
all my energy to another person. Because I actually have some realistic idea of what it takes, and because the world just seems so very very dangerous, even when it's just me and the other people I love who are already on this planet."
The slightly angry reply I wanted to give: I know some of the worst reasons TO have kids - to save a dying marriage, to pass on your genes and call your child Jr. or III in the illustrious line of your heritage. To save you from your loneliness or your boredom, or to have someone else achieve your unfulfilled dreams: get the degree, write the novel, have the career, that you never did, for whatever reason.
To save you from the prospect of an old age where no one takes care of you (using children as an insurance policy, as heatedly discussed on a financial chat site I can't seem to relocate now). To make another human being over in your image - to play God. Or to do it, like my mother's generation, simply because "everyone does it." It's a given.
*****************************************************************
I do think sometimes of missing out on what so many people experience, of never knowing how it feels to give birth, and have that mother-love come over me like a tidal wave, as so many tell me happens the first time they see their own child. I've blanched inwardly when a co-worker told me with awe in her voice how it felt to hold her weeks old baby boy, because it hurt somehow, and I found myself being jealous of something I don't want, and for a moment unsure of my choice. Sometimes I would even get angry when the baby-talk around me at work was too much, and then thought of myself as the "anti-mother" - I pictured myself as some kind of evil goddess, Kali with a skeleton necklace, Medusa with snakes in my hair.
But there has always been so much more to my story than a stereotype of the "un-maternal" woman. I've had an experience many people are fortunate or unfortunate enough not to have had: I've seen, and been deeply affected by, what it means to be a parent. But not just any parent - the parent that my husband is, who was a stay-at-home dad for the first three years of his son's life, who was always (even during teenage years when it got harder), so intimately connected with his child that it's astonishing.
And I know that I wouldn't want to do it with any less dedication, innate ability and passion. But as natural as it feels for so many women to have children, is how unnatural it feels for me. It's possible (though highly unlikely) that this would change one day, but for now I feel it as strongly as any woman listening to her biological clock ticking.
**********************************************************************
Sometimes I think that there is a hidden hand at work in my life, and one of the reasons I ended up with a man 12 years older than me, who had already been a parent, was to make it easier for me to make the decision. And yet it's been the hardest decision of my life.
The fact that my husband wasn't opposed to but also wasn't dying for more kids made it feel like the decision rested mostly on me. And it has intimidated me with its immensity, its existential implications. It's the only life decision most people face that's truly irrevocable - you can get married but if you get divorced then you are no longer someone's spouse, but you can’t really divorce your kid. Unless you give a child up for adoption or (hopefully not!) actually abandon your children, you never cease being a parent, however absent from their lives.
Am I the only one who sees what a weighty choice this is? How frighteningly permanent? For me, the thought always came back to: what if I did it and then regretted it? I'd be stuck. I couldn't bear that.
This is ultimately what I meant when I told my brother that I wasn't up to it, but I don't think he really understood it at the time, I think he just thought I was stubborn. I don't think a lot of people understand, frankly, and that is part of the problem - it's one reason for this feeling of a great divide between parents and non-parents. But it ultimately comes down to lifestyle choices, many of which are not simple decisions and none of which should be viewed as any less valid than others, no matter how in the minority.
**********************************************************************
Also, I know that I'm not completely alone in making this life choice: There are many "childfree" people in the world and many of them are blogging about it (see links below). And even at my stolid ex-workplace I found one woman with whom I could go to lunch and diapers never came up in conversation. We talked about the books we've been reading, writing we've been doing, and how we love words, the texture of them, how slippery they can be, how precise, how heart-breakingly eloquent, raw and needed.
And I get to “mother” in lots of other ways: I am an aunt to my brother's children, and to my friends' children, present and future. I've been sort-of step-parent to this sweet, bright, stubborn, funny, and frustrating now 22 year old, my husband's son from his first marriage. He would call me "step-mom" when introducing me to friends but never really saw me as such, I don't think - rather, I've been a friend who happens to be married to his Dad. And somehow this has worked for us. I've mothered cats, disdainful and sporadically needy as they can be, plants which sometimes die anyway, and poems and projects that don't always come to fruition. I mother my husband when he gets wounded or overwhelmed by the world.
I respect the choice to have children - I admire all the work it takes, the blood, sweat and tears, the years upon years of dedication. But it is my hope that my choice too will be respected and, more importantly, that parents will at least attempt to understand it. I would love it if instead of seeing me as pitiable (she must not have kids because she can't conceive), or enviable (what does she DO with all that extra time and money?) or simply dismissing my husband and I as DINKs (Dual-Income-No-Kids), obviously self-involved and probably selfish, that parents would ask what my life without children is like, how I came to this difficult decision. And my hope is that if I honestly told them, they would truly listen.
Sites listed below do not necessarily represent my personal views, but the discussions sure are interesting!
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Childfree
http://www.childfree.net/
http://www.childfreeclique.com/
http://by-choice.blogspot.com/2009/06/its-about-being-human.html
http://www.babble.com/CS/blogs/strollerderby/archive/2007/03/05/the-childfree-movement-can-t-we-all-just-get-along.aspx
http://www.boston.com/news/globe/magazine/articles/2004/02/22/no_kids_please/